Guides & Changemakers Pilot
Confidential · prepared for Charity Navigator
The 2027 PartnershipStart herePrepared for Charity Navigator · November 2026
PDF
Start here · Built by MatchNice for Charity Navigator
Start here · the whole proposal

The Charity Navigator × MatchNice Partnership, 2027. One main proposal, three ways to grow.

Social matching on every Charity Navigator list and fund by June 1, 2027, the October results behind it, and what comes next. Two minutes for this page; about 49 for everything.

Download the whole proposal as a PDFOne numbered package · 45 pages
How much time do you have?Pick one and we’ll highlight what to read first, in the Guide and the reading list. The whole proposal stays on the page.
Or, what’s your role?We’ll highlight the sections that matter most for your work.
Executive summary
Proposal 1The main proposal
  • Social matching on every Charity Navigator list and fund, live by June 1, 2027. $45,000, funded by a generous funder’s grant. Scope in section 3, the ask in section 4.
  • Why matching works: October’s match on your giving page lifted revenue 13% with 19% less traffic. Section 2 has the full story.
Proposals 2 to 4Partnership growth
  • Proposal 2 · The Nonprofit Lab, Season 2: Charity Navigator becomes the partner of Season 2. Your 4-star charities bring their biggest challenge on air and work it through live with a leader who has solved it before, then come back 30 days later to share what changed. Every episode shows what four stars looks like (section 6).
  • Proposals 3 and 4 are ideas to talk through: impact profiles (with the math and worked examples) and Charity Navigator’s Four-Star badge on MatchNice banners (sections 7 and 8).
  • On top of the build: ten MatchNice features live today, and the roadmap they lead to (section 9).

How to use this app

  1. Move between sections with the Guide: the outline on the left, or the Guide button at the top on a phone. It shows where you are and how far you’ve read. The white arrows between sections and a swipe left or right on a phone work too.
  2. Most sections open with “In 30 seconds” and a list of what’s on them. Tap a line to jump there.
  3. Questions or comments? Tap the Questions bubble at the bottom right. It opens an email to Pooya about the section you’re reading. The bubble also saves the section you’re reading as a PDF.
Reading time
  1. ★ Start here2 min
  2. Proposal 1 · the main proposal
  3. The whole partnership
  4. Partnership growth · proposals 2 to 4
  5. Product
All sectionsAbout 49 min

Times assume about 230 words a minute, rounded up, with a little extra for the mockups you can try.

A note you can paste when you share it

Why I’m sharing this

I’m sharing an app MatchNice built for us. It covers two decisions for 2027.

1 · Social matching, $45,000

Funded by a generous funder’s grant, with matching live on every list and fund by June 1, 2027. October’s match on our dedicated giving page, hosted by GoFundMe Pro, lifted revenue 13%. Case study: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1xJ6GiAnaHmmisa1tN2CW00ECvMg3meG-DAvtW_Yb9wI/edit?usp=sharing

2 · The Nonprofit Lab, Season 2

We send one survey to our 4-star charities, MatchNice pairs them with experts on air, and we get lead sponsor credit all season.

Where to start

Start with section 3, Social Matching Scope, our main proposal. Proposals 2 to 4 are partnership growth. Section 5, Overview, has both decisions on one page.

A message from our CEO
Pooya Pourak

We started MatchNice because generosity is contagious, and a match is the simplest way to prove it. When someone says “I’ll match your gift,” a donor who was only thinking about giving gives today, and often gives more. Every match is a small act of trust between a sponsor, a donor and a charity.

That is why partnering with Charity Navigator means so much to our team. For more than two decades, you have taught donors who to trust. We give them a reason to act on that trust today. October showed what the two do together: our first match on your giving page lifted revenue 13%.

This proposal is our commitment to a long-term partnership: matching on every list and fund, sponsors who come back year after year, and a steady stream of 4-star charities raising more and doing more good. We are proud to build it with you, and we intend to earn your trust for many years to come.

Pooya PourakCo-founder & CEO, MatchNice

Tip: swipe left or right to move between sections.

Context · How Charity Navigator rates

Charity Navigator rates charities to help donors and to celebrate their work. Every proposal here serves one or both.

A one-page refresher on the Encompass Rating System™, in Charity Navigator’s own words, and where each proposal in this app fits.

The goal: more charities registered, opted in and at four stars

Everything in this app serves one goal for Charity Navigator: more charities in the Nonprofit Portal, more of them saying yes, and more of them reaching four stars. Matching is the reason to climb.

1Register moreMore charities claim their profile in the Nonprofit Portal.
2More opt-insMore charities say yes: to completing their data, to matching and to Charity Navigator’s programs.
3More 4-star charitiesMore charities reach a score of 90 or more, the rating that unlocks a match.

Only 4-star charities will be eligible for matches through Charity Navigator. That gives the fourth star a new, concrete value: match dollars. Matching becomes the reason a charity registers, completes its profile and works its way up, and the launch is the moment to ask.

The matching ladder: how a charity moves up

  1. 1RegisterClaims its profile in the Nonprofit Portal. The launch message, “matching is coming for 4-star charities”, brings more charities in at the start.Charity Navigator’s first goal
  2. 2CompleteSubmits the portal data a complete Encompass rating needs. Impact profiles pre-fill much of it with sources (Proposal 3).Proposal 3
  3. 3ImproveSees which beacons hold it below 90, using the four beacons as its checklist (see Proposal 3), and fixes what it can.The four beacons
  4. 4Reach four starsScores 90 or more and becomes eligible. Charity Navigator curates the lists of eligible charities that get matches.Matching eligibility
  5. ★Match and promoteIts match goes live on a list Charity Navigator curates, with Charity Navigator’s Four-Star badge on its MatchNice banner (Proposal 4). Its results bring in the next charities.Proposals 1 and 4

What we’d track, year over year

  • Registered charities in the portal
  • Complete Encompass ratings
  • Charities that moved up at least one star
  • 4-star charities with a live match
  • Match dollars and gifts through Charity Navigator

Each one compared with the same count a year earlier. Starting counts come from Charity Navigator’s own data at launch; we don’t estimate them here.

Why it’s good for Charity Navigator

  • More impact for nonprofits on the Charity Navigator network: matched gifts and new donors for the charities you rate.
  • More registered charities means more complete data, which is the mission.
  • More 4-star charities gives donors more charities they can trust.
  • More giving through your lists and funds, and tip revenue with it: about +$37,250 net cash in 2027 at $1M matched (section 3).
  • A funding story that renews itself: every match is the proof for the next sponsor grant, with a goal of about $50,000 a year from 2028.

How the launch drives it: announce that matching is for 4-star charities, run a registration drive, help charities complete and improve their ratings, and have matches live on every list and fund by June 1, 2027.

How the stars work

Eligible charities get a zero- to four-star rating, from the weighted sum of their metrics (0 to 100).

Star ratings
★★★★90+Great
★★★75–89Good
★★60–74Needs improvement
★50–59Poor
0under 50Very poor

Who is rated: 501(c)(3) public charities with three years of Form 990 filings, which Charity Navigator receives from the IRS. 990-EZ, 990-N and 990-PF filings don’t qualify, and private foundations aren’t rated. A complete Encompass rating also needs data the charity submits through the Charity Navigator Nonprofit Portal.

Two goals, four proposals

“Two objectives drive our approach to rating charities: helping donors and celebrating the work of charities.” Charity Navigator, How We Rate Charities

Goal 1Helping donors
  • Matching on every Charity Navigator list and fund gives donors a reason to give today, where they already check ratings.
  • Donors see what a gift does, with a source on every number.
  • Donors see the rating on the banner where they give, and check it in one tap.
Goal 2Celebrating the work of charities
  • Only 4-star charities get sessions, so every episode showcases good practice.
  • Every 4-star charity can show its rating right where donors give.
  • Helps charities complete the portal data a full rating needs, with no Charity Navigator staff time.
Case study · Our first match together
Approved by Charity Navigator · all figures verified

Revenue up 13% with 19% less traffic. Charity Navigator’s first match, in detail.

In October 2026, Charity Navigator ran its first match with MatchNice on its GoFundMe Pro giving page. Only the match was new. Here is what we ran, how we measured it, and what changed.

The results

+13%Total revenue$11,798 → $13,366
+40%Revenue per visitor$0.82 → $1.14
+6%Conversion ratemore visitors gave
$62Average giftup from $47
56%Gifts from first-time donorsup from 43%
58%Gifts that covered feesup from 51%
−19%Return visitorsas AI search cut traffic

Before and after

The same four days in 2025, with no match, against 2026 with the match.

Total revenue
$11,798$13,366
Revenue per visitor
$0.82$1.14
Average gift
$47$62
First-time donors, share of gifts
43%56%
Gifts that covered fees
51%58%
2025, no match2026, with the match

How we ran it

WhereCharity Navigator’s own giving page

Hosted by GoFundMe Pro.

What was newOnly the match

MatchNice’s match banner on the homepage, plus the website pop-up Charity Navigator already ran.

The matchFunded by board members

Shown in the giving form and at checkout through GoFundMe Pro’s new sponsor matching.

MeasuredSame four days, a year apart

No email or text push in either year.

  1. Go-live date setKyle confirms Charity Navigator can push the match live on October 13.
  2. The match goes liveMatchNice’s banner runs on the homepage and the giving page. The first of three pilot matches planned with Charity Navigator.
  3. GoFundMe Pro sponsor matching switched onGoFundMe Pro had just launched it. The match now shows in the giving form and at checkout too, the first MatchNice campaign to use it.
  4. Thursday to Sunday, measuredCompared with the same days in 2025, when no other campaigns ran.
  5. Results review with KyleRevenue up 13% with 19% fewer return visitors. Next idea: an A/B test of the form with and without the banner.
  6. Case study approvedDeveloped by MatchNice and approved by Charity Navigator, with all figures verified.
Kyle Gardner
“Even with far fewer return site users, we saw a big increase in dollars… All in all, I consider it a rousing success. It’s helping us do more with less.”
Kyle Gardner SVP of Development, Charity Navigator

What it means for 2027

One page, four days and one change lifted revenue 13%. Social matching brings the same match to every Charity Navigator list and fund by June 1, 2027.

· Open the one-page case study

Proposal 1 · main proposal · Social Matching Scope
Main proposal · on track

Matching on every list and fund by June 1, 2027. Here’s the decision and where it stands.

The $45,000 matching contract for 2027, the October 2026 evidence on Charity Navigator’s dedicated giving page, what $1M in matching would mean, and the milestones the team updates.

Social donation matching, 2027

The decision

$45,000 for 2027, funded by a generous funder’s grant (the Matching Sponsor). Matching goes live on curated lists, Causeway Funds and Give Now lists, through the Giving Basket, by June 1, 2027. The 2028 price is set together at the 90-day review, based on 2027 results, and isn’t owed until the platform is live.

What the $45,000 buys

  • $32,000 scope and build, paid at the four gates
  • $13,000 launch and platform: hosting at 99.9%, 60 support hours
  • About 300 MatchNice hours at $150. A flat fee, with no percentage of any dollar.
  • Partner bonus: transactional email build and Q3–Q4 upkeep ($9,000), at no charge
  • Partner bonus: October and December 2026 match fees waived ($1,000 each, $2,000 in all)
  • Early access to everything MatchNice launches. Charity Navigator gets each new feature as it ships, on top of the custom build. The full catalog is below.

Early access to the whole MatchNice catalog

Charity Navigator’s matching runs on the MatchNice platform, so everything below comes to your lists and funds as it ships. Status as of November 16, 2026. AI marks the features where AI drafts the messages or explains the results.

Already in placeWhat Charity Navigator already uses

  1. In placeOne-time match campaignsEvery gift in a window matched, 2X or more. The match behind October.
  2. In placeMonthly giving matchNew monthly donors’ gifts matched to grow recurring giving.
  3. In placeMatch banner and pop-upLive progress and countdown on the giving page.
  4. In placeMatch results reportingBefore-and-after results for each match, as in your case study.

ReleasedLive now, seven of them shipped this November

  1. Nov 9Matcher recognition“Proud Matcher” or “Proud Sponsor” on every banner.
  2. Nov 11Responsive match bannersEvery number on the banner, on every screen.
  3. Nov 15Sponsor FinderAIFind the next matcher in a nonprofit’s own giving history.
  4. Nov 15Sponsor PipelineFive stages from prioritized to confirmed, with stewardship steps.
  5. Nov 15Campaign OutreachAIThe right ask to the right people, ready to copy.
  6. Nov 15Donor Unlock BannerNew monthly donors unlock the match, together.
  7. Nov 16Campaign PagesA match page a nonprofit edits by clicking on the page, with share links, giving chains and the Ripple Map.
  8. LiveOutreach Co-PilotAISponsor asks and donor messages for each donor group, drafted for review.
  9. LivePeer-to-peer matchingA match behind every supporter’s fundraising page.

In the pipelineComing soon, in an order we set with you

  1. Coming soonImpact cardsShow donors what their gift does, once the nonprofit approves.
  2. Coming soonSponsor pagesA page of its own for every match sponsor.
  3. Coming soonSponsor PortalA private home for every sponsor, with live reporting.
  4. Coming soonSponsor personasKnow which sponsor to ask, and when.
  5. Coming soonGuided campaign setupA strong match plan, one question at a time.
  6. Coming soonAudiencesWho to invite, built from the giving history.
  7. Coming soonOutreach that writes itselfAIEvery campaign message, drafted for review.
  8. Coming soonYour match yearEvery match campaign across the year, at a glance.
  9. Coming soonEasy sign-upFrom an EIN to a first match in minutes.
  10. Coming soonResults that get smarterDid the match move the goal?
  11. Coming soonReal-time gift trackingThe banner keeps up with every gift.
  12. In your proposalSponsor and donor emailsAIPersonalized sequences across the nonprofit, sponsor and donor journeys.
  13. Coming soonGiving daysA match that makes a giving day stand out.
  14. In the worksEmployer matchingMatches from donors’ employers, found and claimed.

The evidence: one October 2026 match on Charity Navigator’s dedicated giving page, hosted by GoFundMe Pro

+13%Total revenue, $11,798 to $13,366
+40%Revenue per visitor, $0.82 to $1.14
+32%Average gift, $47 to $62
56%Gifts from first-time donors, up from 43%

Board match, October 2026, compared with the same four days in 2025. Only the match was new: no email or text push. 58% of gifts also covered fees, up from 51%. Source: the case study, approved by Charity Navigator. This is one match over four days, so it’s a strong signal, not a guarantee.

What $1M in matching means, and the return on the $45,000

At this much matched20272028
Matched dollars$1,000,000$2,000,000
Extra giving from donors$130,000*$260,000*
New donors~1,160†~2,320†
Tip revenue to Charity Navigator$28,250‡$56,500‡
Email build and upkeep Charity Navigator avoids about 60 hours at $150$9,000TBD
Net cash to Charity Navigator+$37,250+$60,500before fee

* Modeled on the +13% increase in total revenue from the October 2026 case study match ($11,798 to $13,366), applied to the matched dollars: 13% × $1,000,000 = $130,000.
† New donors assume a 10% new-donor lift at a $112 average gift. The lift is MatchNice’s estimate, based on the case study, where first-time donors rose from 43% to 56% of gifts. The $112 is Charity Navigator’s 2025 Giving Basket average ($51M over 457K gifts). 2028 doubles it with the matched dollars, like the rows above.
‡ Tips are 2.5% of matched dollars plus extra giving: 2.5% × ($1,000,000 + $130,000) = $28,250. The 2.5% tip rate is Charity Navigator’s own figure, from Kyle: about $50,000 in tips on $2M (MatchNice proposal, November 9, 2026, appendix A8).
Other lifts in the same match, not modeled here: +39% revenue per visitor ($0.82 to $1.14) and +32% average gift ($47 to $62).

The return on $45,000

  • For nonprofits: about $1.13M more than donors alone would have given: the $1M match plus about $130,000 in extra giving, and roughly 1,160 new donors.
  • For the Matching Sponsor: each $1 of the $45,000 build unlocks about $2.90 of extra donor giving in year one ($130,000 ÷ $45,000), and keeps working in 2028 and after.
  • For Charity Navigator: about +$37,250 in net cash in 2027, with nothing paid.
  • For donors: every gift goes twice as far with a 1:1 match, on every list and fund, with the sponsor named and the progress live.
  • For MatchNice: a flagship partner and the 2027 results story that brings more sponsors and nonprofits to matching. We earn a flat fee, never a percentage of any gift.

Source: MatchNice executive brief sent to Kyle on November 9, 2026. The table assumes a 1:1 match that is fully used and October’s +13% revenue lift. Matched dollars are planning targets set with Kyle. The $2.90 per dollar and the $1.13M are simple arithmetic on those same figures.

Funding it for years to come: the sponsor dashboard plan

The goal is about $50,000 a year in new matching grants from 2028 on, so matching keeps running year after year. MatchNice is building a sponsor reporting dashboard that turns every match into the proof for the next grant.

ShowA live view for the donor and Charity Navigator: dollars matched, new donors, and the lift on each list and fund.
ReportThe September 30, 2027 sponsor report comes straight from the dashboard, with no extra work for Charity Navigator.
Renew and growThe same proof goes to this donor for a renewal grant and to new matching sponsors, such as foundations and corporate giving teams.

A plan, not a pledge: the $50,000 a year is a target. The dashboard is in development at MatchNice.

Matching milestones

Status shown as of the draft. Sign in to see live team updates.
    Prepared for Charity Navigator

    Thank you for our first match: revenue up 13% and 56% of gifts from first-time donors, with 19% fewer return visitors. Read the case study

    The Nonprofit Lab · Guides & Changemakers pilot

    Send one survey to your nonprofits. We’ll do the rest.

    Nonprofits tell us their biggest challenge. We pair up to three with an expert for a free 30-minute working session on The Nonprofit Lab podcast and share what changed 30 days later. Charity Navigator gets the credit.

    What Charity Navigator does

    1. Send the survey

      Two questions, below. We draft it; you approve and send.

    2. Share the answers

      Answers, plus contacts only for those who said yes.

    3. Co-sign two follow-ups

      How it works, then a match note.

    4. Be TNL’s Season 2 partner

      For all of 2027, with credit across the season.

    5. Amplify more 4-star charities across the sector

      Real fixes on air, proven 30 days later. Let’s go.

    What MatchNice does

    • Sort every answer into themes
    • Recruit and vet expert Guides
    • Pair nonprofits who said yes
    • Host, record and edit sessions
    • Publish an online resource of three things to try
    • Follow up at 30 days and publish the case study
    • Co-author it, with backlinks to each

    The survey, ready to send

    Under 2 minutes · Goal: 400+ answers (±5 pts at 95% confidence) from [list size] sent
    THE EMAIL · FROM CHARITY NAVIGATOR

    Subject: Your biggest challenge, in two questions

    As a 4-star charity, you’re invited to a 2-minute survey with The Nonprofit Lab podcast, which pairs nonprofits with experts for free sessions. Take the survey

    SURVEY INTRO · ABOVE QUESTION 1

    Charity Navigator is the Season 2 partner of The Nonprofit Lab, MatchNice’s podcast, which just released its 100th episode. Each episode pairs a nonprofit leader with an expert on one real challenge and ends with three things to try in 30 days.

    QUESTION 1 · OPEN ANSWER

    What is the biggest challenge your organization is facing right now? Tell us what’s happening and what you’ve tried.

    Type your answer
    Everyone who answers gets first access to [report name].
    QUESTION 2 · YES OR NOT NOW

    As a 4-star charity, you’re eligible for a free 30-minute expert session. Want to learn more?

    Yes, I’m curiousNot now
    Yes just puts you in the running. Recorded for the podcast, up to three per session. Never sold. Nothing public without approval.

    Thank-you screen: “Thank you! Your answer helps shape Season 2 of The Nonprofit Lab. If you said yes, we’ll be in touch.”

    Behind the survey: two databases

    The Changemaker database Fully managed by Charity Navigator

    A secure, private, encrypted database of opted-in nonprofits’ challenges. MatchNice never solicits them unless asked.

    The Guides database Fully managed by MatchNice

    First Guides come from our impact network (3 of 3 said yes); others apply and disclose what they sell.

    MatchNice governance: all opt-in, no PII, never sold. All comms to nonprofits come from Charity Navigator.

    Sponsorship opportunities

    Each pairing can carry one sponsor, who gets:

    • Logo on the episode art
    • Co-branded online resource
    • YouTube + podcast webinar
    • Published case study
    • 30-day results write-up
    • Social post templates
    • Warm intro, if both opt in
    • Permanent show + MatchNice logo
    Potential sponsor revenuePilots free. 2028: episodes × $ = $25,000
    ReleasedDonor Unlock, for monthly givingEvery few new monthly donors unlock part of the match: “3 more donors unlock $600.” A “Remind me” button before launch, and unlocked dollars never go back.For Charity Navigator: a match that grows recurring donors, not only one-time gifts.
    ReleasedEvery-screen banner layoutOn small screens, the match amount stays put and the rest (progress, time left, matcher) rotates in slides, with a swipe guard so a swipe never opens the donation page by mistake.For Charity Navigator: the full match story on every phone.

    Apply free through The Nonprofit Lab. Pay only if selected.

    What Charity Navigator gets

    • Free expert help and anonymized themes
    • A 4-star showcase: only 4-star charities are eligible, with special plugs on the show. Promote episodes to your network.
    • Impact data that can feed the impact beacon of the rating
    • Lead sponsor credit on our website, the podcast’s marketing channels and every episode, webinar, resource and case study

    Proposed 2027 timeline

    JanuaryCharity Navigator sends the survey
    FebruaryThemes to you. 25 problem frames paired with Guides and Changemakers.
    By MarchUp to three sessions recorded
    April–JuneEpisodes, case studies, 30-day results
    July–SeptemberSecond wave of pairings
    October–DecemberYear-end theme report. Season 2 wrap.
    Partnership tracker · Charity Navigator × MatchNice
    Overview · the whole partnership

    One partnership, four lanes. Here’s the plan, who it takes and where it stands.

    Matching on every Charity Navigator list and fund by June 1, 2027. A podcast pilot that turns your nonprofits’ challenges into expert help. And an impact-profile idea for later. Status on this page is shared: anyone on the team can update a milestone.

    Two decisions for 2027: the main proposal and one growth proposal

    How they fit: matching’s projected 2027 net cash to Charity Navigator (+$37,250) is about 2.5 times the $15,000 partnership, and the podcast puts the same 4-star charities and their results on air. Projections use October’s +13% lift; see tab 3.

    The main proposal and partnership growth

    The plan in four lanes

    Every milestone in this app, grouped by who drives it. Status is shared with the milestone lists on each proposal tab: change it in one place and it changes in both.

    1
    Partnership and governanceThe agreement, the people, the four gates and the go or no-go.

    Charity Navigator · Kyle Gardner, SVP DevelopmentMatchNice · Pooya Pourak, CEO

      2
      Product and integrationFrom a test match (timing pending Charity Navigator’s direction) to matching live on every list and fund.

      Charity Navigator · Engineering lead, named by January 15MatchNice · Ibraheem Saleh, CTO

        3
        Marketing and content newTelling the story: the press release, the registration drive, the podcast season and the launch.

        Charity Navigator · Communications lead, to confirmMatchNice · Marketing lead, with Pooya on the podcast

          4
          Sponsors and impactThe money behind the matches, and the proof that brings in the next grant.

          Charity Navigator · Kyle Gardner and the development teamMatchNice · Dickson Nuesse, partnerships

            The press release, registration drive, launch kit and results story are proposals. Charity Navigator’s communications team approves anything issued in its name.

            Who it takes: the stakeholder map

            Matching on every list and fund reaches well beyond one team. Here is everyone the plan needs, from the inside out. The dot shows the lane each one mainly works in. Roles marked “Name to confirm” are our suggestion; Charity Navigator decides who fills them.

            The four lanes, defined. Every role below belongs to one.
            1. 1 · Partnership and governanceThe agreement, the four gates, the money and the go or no-go decisions.
            2. 2 · Product and integrationBuilding matching into the Giving Basket, lists and funds, and keeping it running.
            3. 3 · Marketing and contentThe press release, the registration drive, the launch and the results story.
            4. 4 · Sponsors and impactFinding and keeping matchers, impact profiles and the results each sponsor sees.
            Charity Navigator × MatchNiceone partnership, four lanes

            Inside Charity Navigator

            • Charity Navigator CEOExecutive sponsorChampions the partnership, gives the press release its voice and joins the go or no-go.
            • Kyle GardnerSVP Development · partnership leadOwns the agreement, the four gates and the sponsor relationships. Also picks the pilot list, the match defaults and the copy donors see on Curated lists and Causeway Funds, and shares the baselines and confirms results for the case studies and the sponsor report.
            • Board membersFunded the October matchFirst champions, and natural first matchers for 2027.
            • Project ownerNamed by January 15Runs the weekly working session and keeps the milestones moving.
              Name to confirm
            • Engineering leadNamed by January 15Connects the Giving Basket, lists and funds, and settles the real-time feed.
              Name to confirm
            • Communications and marketingPress, email and socialApproves and issues the press release, the registration drive and the launch.
              Name to confirm
            • Nonprofit outreachNonprofit PortalSends the registration drive and the podcast survey, and helps charities complete their profiles.
              Name to confirm
            • Donor supportDonor questionsAnswers donors’ questions about matches on lists and funds.
              Name to confirm
            • FinanceGrant and paymentsReceives the grant, pays at the gates and tracks match funds.
              Name to confirm
            • Legal and privacyAgreement and data termsReviews the agreement, the data terms and the sponsor terms.
              Name to confirm

            Partners around the platform

            • Matching SponsorA generous funderIts grant funds the $45,000.
            • Give LivelyGiving Basket platformReal-time gift feed, or a scheduled file of gifts (decided by January 15).
            • 2027 matchers and sponsorsFund the matchesPut up the match on each list and fund, and see results on the sponsor dashboard.
            • The Nonprofit Lab GuidesSeason 2 expertsPaired with charities for free working sessions on the podcast.
            • momoGoodExploratoryCould show impact profiles where employees give (Proposal 3).

            Who it reaches

            • 4-star charitiesMatched gifts and new donors
            • Charities climbingA reason to reach four stars
            • DonorsEvery gift goes further
            • Media and the sectorThe press release, launch and results
            MatchNice team:Pooya Pourak, CEOIbraheem Saleh, CTODickson Nuesse, partnershipsMarketing lead

            Later: Charity Navigator Insights idea, not agreed

            If the first survey works, the same opt-in panel can become a standing research service. A live tracker shows what Charity Navigator’s nonprofits are struggling with, theme by theme. Funders, vendors and researchers pay to put questions to nonprofits that opted in, and the sector gets the results. Charity Navigator owns the relationship, MatchNice runs the research, and the split is set together.

            Rough sizing: about 400 answers gives results within ±5 points at 95% confidence, and about 1,070 gives ±3. Needs Charity Navigator’s list size and response rate from the first send.

            Who does what

            AreaMatchNiceCharity Navigator
            Executive sponsor, project, research and designPooya Pourak, CEOKyle Gardner, SVP Development
            Product, engineering and reportingIbraheem Saleh, CTOEngineering lead, TBD
            Matchers, partnerships and launchDickson NuesseProject owner, TBD
            Marketing, press release and launchMatchNice marketing leadCommunications lead, TBD
            Podcast pilot: survey, themes, outreach, sessionsPooya PourakSurvey send and promotion, TBD

            Weekly: a 30-minute working session and a short status note. Monthly and at each gate: a 45-minute steering meeting.

            Partnership growth · Proposal 2 · The Nonprofit Lab, Season 2
            Partnership growth · for review

            One survey, real challenges, expert help on air. Here’s the proposal and the math to 25 episodes.

            A first proposal for review: how the podcast pilot works, how each pairing runs, the business model, and what it takes to get from one survey to 25 episodes.

            The Nonprofit Lab: Guides & Changemakers, Season 2

            Charity Navigator sends one survey and becomes the Season 2 partner of the show for $15,000 in 2027 (separate from the matching contract). Only 4-star charities are eligible for sessions, so every episode showcases good practice and rewards complete profiles, and Charity Navigator can promote each one to its wider network. MatchNice runs everything after the send. Here is how the pieces fit.

            SurveyCharity Navigator sends two questions to its nonprofits.
            ChangemakersOpted-in answers go into a secure, private database of real challenges, sorted into themes and fully managed by Charity Navigator. MatchNice never reaches out to, solicits or promotes its services to these nonprofits unless asked.
            GuidesFully managed by MatchNice. Consultants and solution providers apply with a proposal: the problem, approach, results, what they sell.
            SessionA 30-minute recorded working session, one-on-one or a group of up to three.
            30 daysA follow-up on what changed, then the episode and case study go out.

            How the business model works

            Nonprofits get free expert help. Guides and sponsors pay for the reach. Charity Navigator gets the credit on every piece.

            Who paysGuides and sponsors

            For a consultant or solution provider, a pairing is a qualified lead: a nonprofit that named its problem, a recorded session, and a case study with results. They apply free and pay only if selected. Pricing is set after the pilot.

            Who never paysNonprofits

            Changemakers get a 30-minute working session with an expert, a 30-day follow-up and a published case study, at no cost.

            What’s never soldInformation

            We are not a list-selling business and never will be. Leads and contacts stay out of the public research. Only anonymized themes and approved case studies are published.

            Sponsor revenue forecast · 2028

            The 3 founding pairings are free. Change either number.

            $25,000forecast

            Series and theme sponsors would come on top. A forecast, not booked revenue. Charity Navigator’s $15,000 Season 2 partnership covers 2027.

            The strategy: every pairing feeds the next

            1. A survey wavefills both databases: nonprofits with real problems, and Guides who have solved them.
            2. Each pairingmakes a stack of content: the episode, the webinar, clips, a resource and a case study.
            3. Each case studyis co-authored by the nonprofit, the Guide and MatchNice, and published on every partner’s site.
            4. Backlinks between thembuild search traffic for all three, with Charity Navigator credited on every piece.
            5. That contentbrings in the next wave of nonprofits and Guides, and the loop starts again.

            What every pairing produces

            • Full episodeAudio and video, crediting Charity Navigator
            • WebinarSession published on YouTube and podcast platforms
            • Short clipsMade for social
            • Episode artWith the sponsor’s logo
            • Permanent sponsor logoOn the podcast and on MatchNice
            • Co-branded online resourceFor the blog and knowledge base: three things to try in 30 days
            • 30-day results write-upWhat was tried and what changed
            • Published case studyCo-authored, with backlinks
            • Social post templatesFor the nonprofit, Guide and sponsor
            • Newsletter featureThe pairing, featured in the newsletter
            • Warm introBetween Guide and nonprofit, if both opt in
            • Theme reportAnonymized, for Charity Navigator

            How each pairing runs

            The playbook every pairing follows, from match to published case study.

            Where the first Guides come from

            The founding Guides come from Pooya’s own network of social impact leaders and changemakers. 3 of 3 asked so far said yes. After that, Guides apply with a session proposal: the problem they solve, their approach, past results, and a disclosure of anything they sell. We select on fit to the problem. Paying never buys a slot, and sessions are not sales pitches.

            What every Changemaker and Guide gets

            • A dedicated intro email and a playbook package
            • A warm intro to each other
            • The full episode plan: when it records, when it airs, and the format
            • A prep checklist of what to bring
            • A recommended 30-minute discovery call before recording

            The episode format

            5 minIntroductionThe guest, and the problem in the nonprofit’s own words.
            20 minDiscover, Define, Develop
            • Discover: what is happening, what has been tried, the impact.
            • Define: the real problem, and where roles or handoffs are unclear.
            • Develop: options, the top three to try, one to measure.
            5 minCloseThe plan for the next 30 days. Recording ends.
            Day 30Follow-up interviewWhat was tried, what changed, what failed, what we learned. It becomes the case study and wraps the episode.

            Pooya facilitates with a human-centered design structure: about 30 minutes recorded, plus the 30-day follow-up.

            One pairing, start to finish

            WhenWhat happens
            Week 0Match made. Intro email, playbook package and warm intro go to both sides.
            Week 130-minute discovery call. Record and air dates confirmed. Prep checklist sent.
            Week 230-minute session recorded: 5-minute introduction, 20 minutes of Discover, Define and Develop, 5-minute close.
            Weeks 4–6Episode airs on podcast platforms and YouTube. The online resource is published.
            Day 30Follow-up interview on what changed. It wraps the episode, and the co-authored case study is published with backlinks.

            Ground rules: opt-in at every step, the nonprofit owns its story, learning not critique, contact details stay private, nothing public without approval.

            Podcast pilot milestones

              What it takes to reach 25 episodes

              Each episode needs one confirmed pairing: a Changemaker (a nonprofit with a problem frame) and a Guide. Working back from the goal, here is how many emails Charity Navigator would need to send.

              StageRateNeeded
              Emails Charity Navigator sends
              Complete the survey%
              Say yes to a session%
              Respond and confirm%
              Matched with a Guide%
              Episodes recordedper ep.

              The green boxes are the calculator. Change any rate, the nonprofits per episode, or the episode goal, and the numbers above update.

              Guides side

              • 25 episodes need 25 Guide sessions. One session per Guide means 25 Guides, across the themes the survey finds.
              • 3 of the 3 leaders asked so far said yes.
              • The rest come from MatchNice’s network and from open applications.
              • Sorted by theme, so each problem frame meets a Guide who has solved it before.

              What we need to do

              • Get the list size from Charity Navigator and send to enough 4-star charities to cover the emails needed above.
              • Send one reminder from Charity Navigator about a week after the first email.
              • Follow up on every yes quickly, through Charity Navigator, and book the 30-minute discovery call.
              • Recruit and vet Guides by theme as soon as the themes are in, aiming for a few more than needed.
              • Confirm the 25 problem frames and their pairings in February, then schedule recordings.

              The rates are placeholders to show the math, not benchmarks. Replace them with real numbers after the January send. For comparison, the 400-answer goal on the one-pager, at these rates, gives about 48 pairings.

              Partnership growth · Proposal 3 · Profile completeness for impact
              Partnership growth · for review Exploratory · with momoGood

              Help nonprofits finish their impact story once. Use it everywhere donors give.

              Donors and workplace-giving sponsors want to know what their money did. Most nonprofits never get around to telling them. A three-minute impact profile, pre-filled from public data, could fix that for Charity Navigator profiles and giving platforms like momoGood at the same time.

              Who momoGood is

              momoGood is a giving platform that has served more than 3,000 organizations. It acquired Givergy (events and auctions) and Tatango (text-message fundraising), and it adds workplace giving: employer matching, payroll giving and volunteer tracking for companies and their employees. It is poised to disrupt the corporate social responsibility (CSR) space. Employer and employee gifts flow through it to nonprofits, and its top issue is showing those sponsors and donors what their gifts did. Impact cards help momoGood’s donors trust more, re-engage and give more. Source: momoGood

              Why it matters

              245K+Nonprofits rated by Charity Navigator (its own figure)
              4 · 10 · 17Beacons, evaluation areas, and metrics in the Impact & Measurement beacon
              #1momoGood’s issue: showing employer and donor gifts’ impact back to them
              3 minTarget time for a nonprofit to approve a pre-filled profile

              Complete Charity Navigator profiles rank higher in its search. As of November 10, 2026, Charity Navigator’s API does not yet expose evaluation areas or metrics (“being added”).

              What the profile enriches, in Charity Navigator’s terms

              Charity Navigator’s Encompass rating has four beacons and 10 evaluation areas. A rating needs three years of 990s, and a complete Encompass rating also needs data the charity submits through the Nonprofit Portal. The profile only feeds those portal areas, and only with the nonprofit’s consent. The 17 metrics of the Impact & Measurement beacon are listed one by one.

              Enriches we pre-fill it with sources · Partly we draft part, the org adds the rest · Prompts we ask, the org answers · Not ours we don’t touch it

              MetricProfileWhat we addHow we do itWhy it matters
              Impact & MeasurementHow a charity measures success, and how well its programs perform relative to their cost.
              Impact
              Impact ModelEnrichesProgram, unit served, count and outcome, mapped from reach to outcome, each with a source.Our model reads the 990, annual report and website. The org edits and approves.It’s the heart of the beacon: what a gift actually does.
              Data QualityEnrichesEvery figure tagged guessed, estimated or measured, in Charity Navigator’s own terms.Each field carries its source and a tag. The org can change any tag.Donors and Charity Navigator see how solid each number is.
              Cost Per OutcomeEnrichesThe inputs: all-in cost per unit from the 990 and the org’s count. Charity Navigator and True Impact still judge it against peers.Total expenses from the 990 ÷ the org’s same-year count, rounded up and labeled approximate.The inputs arrive ready, with no math for the nonprofit.
              Cost EffectivenessNot oursCharity Navigator evaluates this itself.Nothing.The judgment stays with Charity Navigator.
              Acquisition of Additional Data and EvaluationsNot oursOutside evaluations are the charity’s own to submit.Nothing.Stays with Charity Navigator.
              Measurement
              Defined Target PopulationEnriches“Who we serve,” drafted from the 990 and website, confirmed by the org.Drafted by our model; the org confirms or edits it in the approval step.Every other measurement metric builds on it.
              Data Collected Across Program LifecyclePartlyAsks whether the org collects baseline and endline data, and records the answer.One yes-or-no question in the approval step, recorded as given.Shows whether results can be compared over time.
              Understood Barriers to AccessPartlyAsks one question on barriers its constituents face.A short prompt; the org answers in its own words.Shows the org knows who it isn’t reaching yet.
              M&E Capacity · M&E System · Data Analysis PracticesPromptsYes or no questions the org answers; we don’t pre-fill these.Asked in the same approval step, never pre-filled.Only the org can answer these honestly.
              Learning
              Reports Results to StakeholdersEnrichesThe published card is a results report to donors and sponsors, refreshed with each 990.The approved card publishes, with consent, to Charity Navigator, momoGood and other platforms.One report reaches donors wherever they give.
              Collects Constituent FeedbackPartlyA consented story and feedback slot the org fills in.The org adds the story. We never collect constituent data ourselves.Puts a real voice next to the numbers.
              Responsible Disclosure · Uses Results to Improve · Leadership Commitment · Feedback PracticesPromptsQuestions the org answers; we never answer for it.Prompts in the approval step.These are practices only the org can speak to.
              Leadership & PlanningWhether the charity has the leadership capacity, strategic development and ability to adapt to deliver on its mission.
              Leadership
              Mission, Vision, GoalsPartlyMission drafted from the 990; the org adds one goal.Mission text from the 990; one prompt for a goal.A clear goal ties the mission to the impact numbers.
              Program Planning
              Sets SMART Objectives · Needs Assessment PracticesPartlyReuses the target population; prompts for one measurable objective.Carried over from Measurement, plus one prompt.One measurable objective makes next year’s results comparable.
              Governance
              Board-approved budget, independent board, minutes, 990 shared with the boardNot oursFrom the 990 and the portal; we don’t touch it.Nothing.Stays with Charity Navigator.
              Accountability & FinanceWhether the charity is accountable, transparent, and financially efficient and sustainable.
              Financial Health · Accountability
              Form 990 ratios and policiesNot oursWe read the same 990 but change nothing.Nothing.Charity Navigator’s financial view stays untouched.
              Culture & CompensationWhether the charity’s practices strengthen its overall organizational health.
              Workplace Policies · Compensation Practices
              Whistleblower and conflict-of-interest policies, CEO pay, benefits and pay policiesNot oursOut of scope.Nothing.Out of scope.

              Scorecard: of the 17 Impact & Measurement metrics, the profile enriches 5, partly fills 3, prompts the org on 7 and leaves 2 to Charity Navigator. Self-reported portal data expires after four years, so the profile refreshes with each new 990. Sources: How We Rate Charities, How Ratings Work (updated Nov 14, 2026) and Impact & Measurement (May 12, 2026).

              How it would work

              InviteThe nonprofit gets an invite from Charity Navigator, with Charity Navigator’s mark.
              Pre-fillMatchNice’s proprietary model, already built and improving with every profile, drafts it from publicly available sources: the 990, annual report, website and more, with a source on every field.
              ApproveThe nonprofit edits and approves in about three minutes. Nothing shows until then.
              Complete and useWith consent, it completes the impact section of the Charity Navigator profile and enriches its nonprofit data. The card also shows to donors and sponsors on momoGood and other giving platforms.
              RefreshEach new 990 or payout prompts a quick “still true?” check, so the profile stays current.

              How everyone wins

              One approved profile moves through every partner, and each step leaves someone better off. The loop closes when donors see more impact, trust grows and the next gift comes back to the nonprofit.

              1. NonprofitApproves its profile once.Wins: a complete story used everywhere, less reporting work.
              2. MatchNiceOur model pre-fills; the nonprofit edits and confirms.Wins: runs the profile, pairs it with matching, reports to sponsors.
              3. Charity NavigatorWith consent, the answers complete its profile.Wins: more complete profiles and impact data, no staff time.
              4. momoGood and other platformsShow the card where the gift happens.Wins: donors who trust more, re-engage and give more, plus wrap-ups for employer sponsors.
              5. Donors and sponsorsSee what their gift did.Wins: more impact shown, more trust, a reason to give again.

              ↻ More trust brings the next gift, and the match, back to the nonprofit.

              The impact card example, not org-approved

              Every nonprofit gets the same template. It edits the card, confirms it and chooses whether to publish. Publishing updates its impact profile everywhere it shows. Try the buttons below; this demo saves nothing.

              Girl Scouts of Greater AtlantaEIN 58-0566190 · FY ending Sept. 2025
              Draft · not approved
              About $760all-in cost per girl served per year, about $63 a month 1, 2
              Who we serve
              Over 22,000 girls a year 2
              Total expenses
              $16,734,154 1
              How we calculated
              Total expenses ÷ girls served. An average across all programs, all costs included.
              In our words
              A quote from the organization goes here. We never write it for them.
              1. Form 990, FY ending Sept. 2025, total expenses (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer)
              2. Same Form 990, Part III program accomplishments: “over 22,000 girls”

              Powered by MatchNice · Draft until the nonprofit publishes

              Also for Season 2 of the podcast: after each episode, the Changemaker gets a card in the same template, pre-filled from the session (the problem, three things to try, the 30-day result). It edits, confirms and chooses to publish, and the card updates its impact profile.

              The four beacons, and where the impact card fits

              Highlighted Impact profiles pre-fill it with sources, or ask the org · Plain Charity Navigator scores it as today, untouched

              Impact & Measurement

              How a charity measures success, and how well its programs perform relative to their cost.

              Impact

              • Impact Model
              • Data Quality
              • Cost Per Outcome
              • Cost Effectiveness
              • Acquisition of Additional Data and Evaluations

              Measurement

              • Defined Target Population
              • Data Collected Across Program Lifecycle
              • Understood Barriers to Access
              • Invested in M&E Capacity
              • Established M&E System
              • Data Analysis Practices

              Learning

              • Reports Results to Stakeholders
              • Collects Constituent Feedback
              • Leadership Commitment to M&E
              • Responsible Disclosure of Results
              • Uses Results to Improve Programs
              • Feedback Practices
              Leadership & Planning

              Whether the charity has the leadership capacity, strategic development and ability to adapt to deliver on its mission.

              Leadership

              • Mission, Vision, Goals
              • Leadership Investment
              • External Engagement
              • Adaptability

              Program Planning

              • Sets SMART Objectives
              • Needs Assessment Practices
              • Shared Understanding of Theory of Change
              • Theory of Change Practices
              • Monitoring & Evaluation Practices

              Governance

              • Board-Approved Budget
              • Independent Board Size
              • Independent Board Majority
              • Document Board Minutes
              • Tax Form Distributed to Board
              Accountability & Finance

              Whether the charity is accountable, transparent, and financially efficient and sustainable.

              Evaluation areas

              • Financial Health
              • Accountability

              Scored from the 990 and policies. No proposal here changes it.

              Culture & Compensation

              Key workplace policies and practices, and compensation practices.

              Workplace Policies

              • Whistleblower Policy
              • Conflict of Interest Policy
              • Workplace Policies
              • Hiring and Employee Performance Practices

              Compensation Practices

              • Board Compensation
              • CEO Salary Disclosed
              • CEO Compensation Policy
              • Employee Benefit Ratio
              • Promotional Pay Policy
              • Reviewed Compensation Structure

              Impact profiles never answer for a charity and never change a score. Charity Navigator scores every metric as it does today. Sources: Charity Navigator, How We Rate Charities and its beacon pages for Impact & Measurement, Leadership & Planning and Culture & Compensation, read November 14, 2026.

              The math behind the card

              One number does the work: what it costs, all in, to deliver one unit of the nonprofit’s work. It comes from the nonprofit’s own Form 990, so anyone can check it. Here is the whole calculation.

              1. Find the unit and the count. The model reads Part III (program accomplishments) and Schedule O for one countable unit the nonprofit reports for that year: girls served, meals, homes. It quotes the sentence it used. Lifetime totals and pipeline counts are ignored.
              2. Divide, same year only. Total expenses ÷ that count. Costs and counts must come from the same fiscal year. If a newer annual report has a newer count, it is shown for the nonprofit to confirm, never mixed into the math.
              3. Round up and say “about.” Up to the next dollar (the next cent under $10), so a gift is never overstated. “All in” means staff, rent and overhead are included, so the number is honest about what a gift really supports.
              4. One program instead of all of them. When a nonprofit picks one program, overhead is shared out in proportion: program expenses × (total expenses ÷ total program expenses) ÷ that program’s count.
              5. Turn it into a gift ladder. $25, $50, $100 and $1,000, each on its own and with a 1:1 match. Counts are rounded down. The size of the unit sets the wording (below).
              6. Check it before anyone sees it. Same-year check, a count check against the annual report (within 2%), a peer check (more than 2× the median for similar programs goes to a person), and a note when donated goods are part of the expenses.
              Small unit · $100 or lessThe ladder counts units.“$25 helps provide about 10 meals.”
              Medium unit · $100 to $1,000Time or share below one unit, whole units from $1,000.“$100 helps provide about 6 weeks of Girl Scouts for a girl.”
              Big unit · over $1,000Shares, plus a team rollup once pooled gifts reach a whole unit.“Your team’s gifts and matches helped provide about 2 homes this year.” (illustrative)

              In Charity Navigator’s terms, this is a cost per output (a unit delivered), not a cost per outcome. It gives the Cost Per Outcome metric clean, sourced inputs. Charity Navigator and its impact partners still judge outcomes and cost-effectiveness. Every figure starts as estimated (from the 990) and becomes reported once the nonprofit confirms it.

              Three worked examples public 990 data, not org-approved

              Three Atlanta nonprofits, run through the method above from their latest public Form 990s. They show the three things the model does: a small unit, a medium unit, and a case where it stops and asks. None of these nonprofits has seen or approved these numbers.

              1 · Small unit: Atlanta Community Food BankEIN 58-1376648 · fiscal year ending June 2025
              Draft · estimated
              $260,439,580 total expenses [1] ÷ 112.3 million meals [1] = $2.319 → about $2.32 a meal, all in
              GiftOn its ownWith a 1:1 match
              $25about 10 mealsabout 21 meals
              $100about 43 mealsabout 86 meals
              $1,000about 431 mealsabout 862 meals
              • Flag for the nonprofit: the 990 says the food was “enough for over 112.3 million meals” combined with approved SNAP applications. The model shows that wording and asks the food bank to confirm the meal count before the card goes live.
              • Flag, donated goods: the same 990 reports $196,359,574 of non-cash contributions (Part VIII, line 1g). The all-in figure counts donated food at its value, and the card says so.
              2 · Medium unit: Girl Scouts of Greater AtlantaEIN 58-0566190 · fiscal year ending September 2025 · the card above
              Draft · estimated
              $16,734,154 total expenses [2] ÷ 22,000 girls [2] = $760.64 → about $761 per girl per year (about $63 a month, $14.63 a week)
              GiftOn its ownWith a 1:1 match
              $25about 1 week for a girlabout 3 weeks
              $100about 6 weeksabout 13 weeks
              $1,000about 1 girl for a full yearabout 2 girls for a full year
              • Count is a floor: Part III says “over 22,000 girls,” so the true cost per girl is at or below $761. The card says “about.”
              • One program instead: the camp program spent $5,266,546 on “over 9,000 experiences” [2]. Sharing overhead in proportion ($16,734,154 ÷ $13,921,270 total program expenses) gives about $704 per camp experience. The 990 counts experiences for girls and adults, so the nonprofit would confirm the unit.
              3 · When the model stops: Atlanta Habitat for HumanityEIN 58-1535414 · fiscal year ending December 2024
              Needs the nonprofit
              $24,068,495 total expenses [3]. One program line reports 47 new houses and 175 houses repaired or repainted [3].
              • Why it stops: the 990 doesn’t split costs between new homes and repairs. Dividing everything by 47 homes would say about $512,000 a home, which overstates it because repairs share those costs. The model never publishes a number like that.
              • What it does instead: it asks the nonprofit two questions (which unit to show, and roughly what share of program costs it takes), then runs the same math. Until then, nothing shows.

              The output: one record per nonprofit

              Each card is saved as a versioned record. With the nonprofit’s consent, this is what a giving page, a sponsor report or Charity Navigator’s profile would read. Example 2, as a draft:

              "ein": "58-0566190",  "status": "draft",  "data_quality": "estimated",
              "unit": "girl served per year",  "count": 22000,  "count_source": "990 Part III, line 4a",
              "fiscal_year": "Oct 2024 to Sep 2025",  "total_expenses": 16734154,
              "all_in_cost_per_unit": 761,  "unit_size": "medium",
              "ladder": [ { "amount": 100, "matched": 200,
                           "line": "$100 helps provide about 6 weeks of Girl Scouts for a girl" } ],
              "flags": [ "count is a minimum (over 22,000)" ],
              "sources": [ { "n": 1, "title": "Form 990 FY2025", "lines": "Part I line 18; Part III 4a" } ],
              "approved_by": null,  "valid_until": "18 months after approval, or the next 990"   // draft until the nonprofit approves
              1. Atlanta Community Food Bank, Form 990, FY ending June 30, 2025: Part I line 18, Part III line 4a, Part VIII line 1g. ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer
              2. Girl Scouts of Greater Atlanta, Form 990, FY ending Sept. 30, 2025: Part I line 18, Part III lines 4a and 4b, Part IX line 25. ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer
              3. Habitat for Humanity in Atlanta, Form 990, FY ending Dec. 31, 2024: Part I line 18, Part III line 4a. ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer

              Guardrails

              The model drafts; people decide. Every card has to clear these before a nonprofit even sees it, and again before it publishes.

              1. 95% accuracy, proven, not assumed. Each model version is checked on a blind human audit of at least 400 fields. It ships only if the lower end of the 95% confidence interval is at or above 95%. For example, 392 of 400 correct (98%) gives a lower bound of 96.1% and passes; 388 of 400 (97%) gives 94.8% and fails.
              2. 95% consistency. Each profile is drafted three times. The figures must match across the three runs, with the agreement rate’s 95% lower bound at or above 95%. Any field that disagrees goes to a person.
              3. The gate applies per field type. Counts, costs, populations and missions are scored separately, so a strong field can’t hide a weak one.
              4. A linked source on every figure. Each number carries a numbered, public link. No link, no figure.
              5. Confidence shown on every field. High, medium or low. Low-confidence fields stay hidden until the nonprofit fills or confirms them.
              6. Nothing public without approval. Every card is a draft until the nonprofit edits, confirms and chooses to publish. It can unpublish at any time.
              7. Never invent. No made-up outcomes, quotes, stories or photos. The “in our words” slot is written by the nonprofit only.
              8. Charity Navigator’s data-quality terms. Every figure is labeled guessed, estimated or measured.
              9. Same-year figures. Costs and counts must come from the same fiscal year. Mismatches are flagged, and cards refresh with each new 990 and expire if not reconfirmed.
              10. Peer sanity check. A cost per unit far outside the range for similar programs goes to human review before the nonprofit sees it.
              11. Honest wording. “Helps provide about,” all-in averages labeled as such, and a how-we-calculated link on every card.
              12. Never promise a rating change. Charity Navigator rates. The profile only helps complete it.
              13. Consent and privacy. Answers go to Charity Navigator only with the nonprofit’s consent. No donor PII. All messages to nonprofits come from Charity Navigator.
              14. Full audit trail. Every card records the model version, inputs, sources, edits and who approved it. Corrections from nonprofits are logged and used to improve the model.
              15. Fair to small nonprofits. Organizations that are listed but not rated, or that file a short 990, get the same template and simply answer more questions themselves.
              16. No percentage fees. Nonprofits never pay a cut of gifts for their card.

              Next steps

                Partnership growth · Proposal 4 · The Four-Star badge on MatchNice banners
                Partnership growth · for review Pulled from the Charity Navigator API

                Every 4-star charity can add Charity Navigator’s Four-Star badge to its MatchNice banner. Trust, right next to the match.

                Any nonprofit on MatchNice that holds four stars can add the Four-Star badge as an object on its banner. MatchNice reads the rating from Charity Navigator’s API, so it is always current, and the badge sits beside the match, the donor count and the Give button, right where donors decide.

                See it: the Four-Star badge on a MatchNice banner

                A sample on a made-up nonprofit, in the style of MatchNice’s Donor Unlock banner and in Charity Navigator’s colors. The numbers are a sample.

                example-rescue.org
                Example Animal Rescue
                Charity Navigator Four-Star badge
                Every 5 monthly donors
                unlock a $500 match
                3 of 5 monthly donors joined
                $2,000of $12K unlocked so far
                Rated Four-Star by Charity NavigatorTap the badge for our profile
                Give monthly
                Banner settings
                Preview

                On a phone, the badge and the Give button stay put while the messages rotate every 2.5 seconds.

                How it would work

                1. Match the charityMatchNice already links each account to its Charity Navigator profile through the API.
                2. Check the ratingIf the charity holds four stars today, the badge appears in its banner settings, switched off until it opts in.
                3. Add the badgeOne toggle. It sits on the banner next to the match, and tapping it opens the charity’s Charity Navigator profile.
                4. Stay currentMatchNice re-checks the rating daily. If it changes or lapses, the badge updates or hides itself.

                How everyone wins

                Charity NavigatorIts Four-Star mark on every 4-star charity’s banner, at the moment donors decide, and more visitors to its profiles.
                NonprofitsA free trust signal next to the Give button, with nothing to design.
                DonorsProof the charity is well run, right where they give.
                MatchNiceTrust that strengthens every match it powers.

                Guardrails and next steps

                • Only the current rating: the badge shows only for charities that hold four stars today, read from Charity Navigator’s API.
                • Charity Navigator approves the mark, the wording and the design before anything ships.
                • No donor data is shared. The badge only links to the charity’s public profile.
                • Later: show the Charity Navigator score itself, and beacons such as Impact & Measurement, once Charity Navigator’s data terms allow it.
                • Next step: agree on the brand rules and the API fields, then pilot with 25 4-star charities that run matches on MatchNice, and compare gift rates and profile visits with and without the badge.

                Also: the same badge as a website footer

                From our September 2026 proof of concept: a 4-star charity installs it with one snippet, or an embed for Wix, Squarespace or WordPress. Its button goes to the charity’s Charity Navigator profile or to its donate page. A mockup on a made-up nonprofit.

                example-rescue.org
                Example Animal Rescue
                Charity Navigator Four-Star badgeProudly rated 4 stars by Charity NavigatorDemonstrating verified financial health, accountability and impact.View our profile
                Product · Released and roadmap

                Ten features live today. Better every week, from real campaigns.

                Everything here runs on one MatchNice platform. Released means live in the product today. Rebuilding now means we are improving it right now, based on what nonprofits told us and what we saw in real campaigns. On the roadmap is where we are headed. AI marks the features where AI drafts the messages or explains the results; people always review and send. Status as of November 16, 2026.

                In 30 seconds
                • 10 features live: matching and recognition, mobile-ready banners, MatchID, Campaign Pages, Donor Unlock, Outreach Co-Pilot and peer-to-peer matching.
                • Rebuilding now, from real use: a simpler Campaigns list, integrations you can finish yourself, a sign-up that fills itself in and the next Campaign Page Builder.
                • Where it’s headed: Co-Pilot guided setup, a match-year calendar, a portal and pages for sponsors, and giving days.
                • How we ship: a test group first, then full testing, then release notes for everyone.
                On this tab

                Live today

                ReleasedMultiply every giftEach gift in a set window is matched, 2X or more, with a live banner showing progress and the deadline.Why it matters: a deadline and a multiplier give donors a reason to give today, not someday.
                ReleasedMatcher recognitionAn optional “Proud Matcher” or “Proud Sponsor” label on the banner names who made the match possible.Why it matters: sponsors see their name on every gift, which makes asking them again easier.
                ReleasedBanner modernization and mobile optimizationThe match banner adjusts to the screen it’s on, from desktop down to a phone.Why it matters: donors on phones see the whole match, not a cut-off banner.
                ReleasedMatchID: Sponsor FinderAIA nonprofit uploads its gift history once. Names, emails, phones and addresses are stripped before anything is stored. Each donor gets a 0 to 100 score for the campaign, plain-English reasons, Safe, Balanced and Bold ask sizes, and the best month to ask.Why it matters: your next match sponsor is often already in your own giving history.
                ReleasedMatchID: PipelineFive stages from Prioritized to Confirmed. A confirmed pledge opens a four-step stewardship checklist and adds the sponsor to the campaign, shown by name, anonymously, in honor or memory of someone, or with a logo.Why it matters: every sponsor conversation in one place, from the first ask to the thank-you.
                ReleasedMatchID: Campaign OutreachAIReady-to-copy sponsor asks for every campaign, plus messages for five donor audiences, such as lapsed donors and donors ready for a second gift. The nonprofit always reviews and sends.Why it matters: less time writing asks, and every message stays yours to review and send.
                ReleasedCampaign PagesA ready-made match page a nonprofit edits by clicking on the page itself, with one impact line per page. Share links, giving chains and the Ripple Map are built in: each donor gets a gift link, and gifts made through it ripple out on a live map, with no names or amounts shown.Why it matters: a match page that looks finished in minutes, and that donors share for you.
                ReleasedDonor Unlock BannerNew monthly donors unlock the match together, with the every-screen banner layout (Nov 15).Why it matters: turns one busy giving moment into new monthly donors.
                ReleasedOutreach Co-PilotAIDrafts sponsor asks and donor messages for each donor group, built on MatchID. The nonprofit always reviews and sends.Why it matters: real help for small teams with no fundraising staff.
                ReleasedPeer-to-peer matchingMatches what supporters raise on their own fundraising pages.Why it matters: supporters’ own fundraising pages get the match too, which suits giving days.

                Rebuilding now, from real use

                We watched nonprofits set up and run real campaigns, end to end. These are the changes they asked for most, and they are being built now.

                Rebuilding nowA simpler Campaigns listOne clean table: name, type, status (Draft, Scheduled, Live or Ended), raised against goal, supporters and dates, with search and filters. Each campaign gets its own Overview, and ended campaigns stay in the list.Why it matters: see every campaign and how it is doing at a glance.
                Rebuilding nowIntegrations you can finish yourselfEvery step shows as a numbered checklist that ticks itself off, with screenshots, one button per step and a short video. Send the steps to your web admin in one click, and finish with a $1 test gift that proves it works.Why it matters: no guessing whether the match is really connected to your giving form.
                Rebuilding nowSign-up that fills itself inEnter your EIN or your name, and your website and address fill in for you.Why it matters: fewer forms between you and your first match.
                Rebuilding nowThe next Campaign Page BuilderThe builder behind Campaign Pages gets its biggest upgrade yet, so your page looks finished from the first click.Why it matters: a page you are proud to share, without a designer.
                Rebuilding nowDonor Unlock, inside campaign setupSet up a monthly-donor unlock while you build the campaign, instead of as a separate step.Why it matters: recurring giving becomes part of every match, not an add-on.
                Rebuilding nowFriendlier emails from MatchNiceYour logo, the person’s name, one clear button and warm words. Sent at the reader’s local time, never more than one a day or three a week, and they stop after three nudges.Why it matters: emails people are glad to get, and act on.

                Where it’s headed

                On the roadmapCo-Pilot guided setupCo-Pilot walks you through setting up a match, one question per screen, and suggests what to do next.Why it matters: your first match, set up with a guide beside you.
                On the roadmapA match-year calendarEvery match moment of your year, such as year-end, Giving Tuesday and your giving days, in one calendar on your Home page.Why it matters: plan the year’s matches, and the sponsors behind them, months ahead.
                On the roadmapSponsor Portal and live reportingSponsors follow their match live and get the full wrap report at the end.Why it matters: the renewal story for every sponsor, written for you.
                On the roadmapSponsor pagesEach match sponsor gets its own page and map on its own link, for its employees and network to share.Why it matters: sponsors promote your match to their own people.
                On the roadmapSponsor and donor emailsAIPersonalized email sequences across the nonprofit, sponsor and donor journeys.Why it matters: the right message to each person, without building it by hand.
                On the roadmapImpact profilesA pre-filled impact card, shown only once the nonprofit approves it, with the math shown.Why it matters: donors see what a gift does, with a source on every number.
                On the roadmapDollar milestones and first gift multipliedThe match unlocks in steps as dollars come in, or a new monthly donor’s first gift is matched for 3 to 12 months.Why it matters: more match formats for different sponsors and goals.
                On the roadmapGiving daysMatching built for community giving days, alongside your own campaigns.Why it matters: a reason for the whole community to give on the same day.

                How we ship

                1. A test group firstA new feature turns on for a small group of nonprofits before anyone else.
                2. Tested end to endOur quality and user testing walks through every step, from sign-up to a live match, on desktop and phone.
                3. Released to everyoneIt turns on for all nonprofits once it passes.
                4. Release notesYou get a short note on what changed, why, and what to try first.

                Your feedback sets the order. Everything under “Rebuilding now” came from nonprofits using MatchNice.

                What it adds for Charity Navigator, on top of the build

                One platform, not a one-offThe 2027 build sits on the MatchNice platform, so releases like these can reach your lists and funds without a new project.
                More nonprofits ready to matchMatchID and Outreach help the nonprofits you rate find and ask their own sponsors.
                Sponsors who renewRecognition, sponsor pages and live reporting give every sponsor a reason to come back next year.

                For Charity Navigator: “Multiply every gift” is the match type behind October’s +13% on your giving page. We’ll pick together which of the rest come to your lists and funds first, as part of the 2027 plan.